Another common misconception of many, including Christ-followers, is God’s discipline = punishment. We automatically ASSUME God is punishing us for all the wrong we have done. We hear our earthly father say, “This is going to hurt me more than it hurts you” then they high-tail our rear end and we have serious doubts that is true. So we ASSUME God is the same way. Not so.
Christ fully and completely satisfied the Father’s anger so that I will never again face the penalty for my sin. (Tripp)
We want to judge God the same way we judge man. But God cannot be held to the same standards as us. That’s like holding a husky to the same criteria as a goldfish. The dog is going to drown, or the fish will dry out. We cannot do that to God. God’s discipline is not punishment. Punishment tears down; discipline builds up. Punishment is designed to put someone in the “right” place; discipline is designed to keep us in the “right” place. God’s desire for discipline is not to slam me; it is to transform me. So, as Tripp says at the end, “God’s discipline is an instrument of grace.” That’s good news to me. when I sin or fall or fail, God is not waiting to give me 7 lashes with a belt: He’s waiting to extend grace and forgive. After all, my punishment was taken care of at the cross. I’m his now. New. Free. Clean. Redirected. Transformed.
“Father, thank you that you love me enough to discipline me. Thank you that your discipline is a sign of your love and not retribution for bad deeds done. I know I’ll mess up; fall; fail. I look for your continued grace. Help me to “see” evidence of that grace. Let it transform me.”


Vicarious redemption is an immoral construct of certain theistic belief systems. Check this out if you dare:
https://argumentsagainstreligion.com/2015/11/05/vicarious-redemption/
i dared Jeff. I will read it again when I have more time. Hitchens is such a hero to you and the guy who wrote that. He or you may want to check out The Faith of Christopher Hitchens and The Grace Effect, both by Larry Alex Taunton. Although he never came to know Jesus as His Savior, Hitchens “recanted” a lot of what he spouted off earlier. Just saying…
Actually Hitchen’s close friends suggested Taunton misread Hitchens true feelings although they did become friends.
Sounds like a he said/she said thing. Or it sounds like sour grapes by his friends trying to defend Hitchens’ “change” of attitude. What made the real difference was Larry’s adopted daughter, Grace.
Hope this is past when your followers are paying attention. You know your comment of he said/ she said may be a weak try to defend Taunton who is a crackpot Christian of which you have identified several. Bill, you are on the wrong side of reality. Go deliver Pizzas. You will die happier. Jesus is BS. I will no longer participate in your fantasy of life. Bye
I personally don’t see a problem with a perfect father wanting to find a way to have a relationship with His fallen children…
I find it interesting that the argument is based on what is unjust.
Without an absolute measure of what just is and what just is not… justice is relative. Justice is based on who is in power at the time. What is right and what is wrong is nothing more than majority rule or the rule of an imperfect dictator.
You said it well Ryan “without an absolute measure…” If we choose to live our lives without the absolute measure of God’s Word then it is fair game for all.
Absolutely, Bill! God doesn’t punish, He disciplines for our own good. Such a blessing!
I’m glad you were able to get my point Martha. Let’s me know I made sense! 🙂
A couple lines from the devotion stuck out to me this morning…
“If you obey God for a thousand years, you will not have earned more of his acceptance than you were granted the very first moment you believed.”
And then most of the 2nd paragragh.
And Bill you make the distinction a bit better a believe… in regards to punishment vs discipline.
“Rather than being punitive, his fatherly discipline is transformative. It is designed to change your heart.”
As a father of teenagers, I have tried to change my model to be disciplining vs punishing…
This takes a higher level of discipline of myself. Punishment is generally pretty easy. You do this, you get that. Discipline is more involved. It requires digging in deep, having tougher conversations, trying to understand the heart vs the action.
I am thankful God uses that model on me. I am thankful he wants to change my heart and not just my actions. Changing actions is like a manager or a boss assigning tasks to complete. God is my Father, and His purpose is much deeper than that of a task master. He longs for a relationship that requires my heart to be changed.
Have a great day!
You have hit on the difference also Ryan. use discipline to train and teach. And you are so right when you say it takes more work on our part. UGH!
Excellent summary on the differences between discipline and punishment.
In God’s perfect economy there are consequences to our choices.
Thanks Floyd. How quickly we do forget the consequences with our choices.
Jeff: I’m sorry to see you go but you and I will always be on opposite sides of the spectrum. My biblical worldview will always clash with your carnal, ungodly worldview. You say there is no God (least one interested in us) and that Jesus is BS. (Bad choice of words). Anyway, I know you don’t believe what I am going to say but I do care about you. I care about your soul. I care about your eternity. However, please keep this in mind: when you stand before the God whom you say doesn’t exist and he says, “Depart from me I never knew you” remember there was someone who warned you about what was to come.
Also I am not negating what Taunton did or said (per your links). His indiscretion notwithstanding, I am still holding to the truth of a God who lives. I don’t discount the one but the other sounds like I’m trying to defend “my guy” and your atheist comrades are trying to defend “their guy.” Guess we will see when it either comes from Larry’s mouth or in eternity.